If you pick Boland, it's just pretty stupid really. Given what had gone before, the spot really shouldn't have been up for grabs in these matches.
Was kinda my point. If we picked Boland we'd be picking a similar if not worse player and would then have the problem of finding a new spot for McGrath.
The problem isn't McGrath, It's that Boland shouldn't start ahead of Slogga. Boland is closer as a backup batsman than as competition for the keeping spot atm.
McGrath has a great record at 5 (because he's a cat etc etc) but Slogga should have been so far ahead of Boland before these games that it doesn't really matter. It'd be like picking Tait ahead of Fiery.