No massive advantage though from 1st to 4th in that list. Probably the biggest advantage is that Tart & Rego are really going to struggle at the line-out. Though Escath may be negated by Irottev being an atrocious hooker, so he may not be able to throw straight.
Backs Escath XV Tart's TTs Steve's XV Thunder RFC Could be the most important difference here. Escath's back line is more than 2x better than Rego's.
All the good ones were taken by the time I got all the people I really wanted to pick up and the rest all seemed pretty dire so I left it till the last round. Win.
Set Piece Rankings Scrum Steve's XV Escath's XV Thunder RFC Tart's TTs Line Out Escath's XV Steve's XV Thunder RFC Tart's TTs Ruck Escath's XV Steve's XV Thunder RFC Tart's TTs Maul Steve's XV Escath's XV Thunder RFC Tart's TTs Tart set to struggle at the set-piece.
So basically overall Eskimos > everyone else. That's before taking into account the Fail Escath Simmage factor that is such a key factor in CricSim and IHS. Will probably be incorporated into the team I picked here.
Overall Ratings (the lower the better) Escath's XV (24) Steve's XV (34) Tart's TT (34) Thunder RFC (40)