I would rate it as a 4 so far. It does enough for the moment. Eventually the big thing will be incorporating post ranks.....however a long way to go yet.
Yeah, think Priddo listed a few reasons why we're not using them... I think the main reason was we'd need twice as many players/half as many teams. which he wans't keen for.
A bit too defensive for my liking, but i'm sure that will change.... It's hard to do updates play by play because well, it gets very ****ing boring and pointless
If you make it more attacking the defensive players and goal keeper postion are pointless. The balance is right so far. If form could be added into the sim somehow goal keepers are letting more goals in then they should, or attacking player can't seem to score would be good addition. More details in each quater. Plus the quaters stats would be nice also.
Five from me. Simulator could use some work although I'm sure you know that, and that's not what this thread is about. You've done an awesome job.