In my lifetime: Club: 1. Wayne Carey 2. Brent Harvey 3. Anthony Stevens 4. Adam Simpson 5. Ben Cunnington (going early on this one) League: 1. Gary Ablett Jnr 2. Wayne Carey 3. Chris Judd 4. Michael Voss 5. Anthony Koutafides
Geelong: 1. Gary Ablett jnr 2. Matthew Scarlett 3. Joel Selwood 4. Jimmy Bartel 5. Corey Enright AFL: 1. Gary Ablett jnr 2. Chris Judd 3. Michael Voss 4. Nick Riewoldt 5. Matthew Scarlett My AFL memory is from about 2002 onwards. Been watching footy since 1997 really, but I don't have many memories prior to 2002 so that's where my list is from. Also I've seen all these players live, never saw Carey, etc. live.
Adelaide: - Dangerfield - Ricciuto - McLeod - Goodwin - Edwards AFL: - Judd - Ablett jr. - Pavlich - Franklin - N.Riewoldt
North: (Peak) 1. Wayne Carey 2. Corey McKernan 3. Brent Harvey 4. Peter Bell 5. Micky Martyn/Anthony Stevens Altogether: 1. Wayne Carey 2. Chris Judd 3. Gary Ablett 4. Matthew Lloyd (Always tore us apart) 5. Simon Black