Watching the games live usually gives you the best indication of who steps up and when they who fails when the pressure is on. Who takes the wickets when they are needed most etc etc. There's only so much you can tell from a scorecard, at the end of the day there's only enough room for a few numbers.
As I mentioned but it's minimal. Watching it live is the best way to get a grasp on whose performances were the best so if he's arguing the accurateness of Morgieb's reasons then he can't even back his up not having watched any games live... capiche?
Tbh, you can tell a fair bit from a scorecard and really, I havent watched any ALC games live considering I have only been back on for the last couple of days, im just expressing a biased view.
http://www.cricsim.com/site/match.php?id=1347 I nominate that as my best single game performance... 179 runs @ 179 9 wickets @ 14.11
http://www.cricsim.com/site/match.php?id=1475 That wasn't too bad tho 172 runs @ 172 9 wickets @ 9.67