First draft - new sim player attributes

Don't worry i got the message awhile ago, but your point is fail because basically you aren't needed... he will be good with you, and just as good without you, basically you will make no difference whatsoever.

 

Exactly why you kept replying, ey. Do you really think I don't recognise that with your massive post count you won't be a good player next season. But honestly if you think that his success lives and dies on your back you really need to get a reality check, because there are players at each of the clubs who would be there to help him be more succesful. For exaple If he were at the Hawks with Gayler and Toolman, he would be better off then running off you IMHO.

 

Disagree, if he were a creative fullback then I would say yes, he would be better in broken play ie off offloads, but as a running fullback he would be better off running into holes which means he is better off on a team with good structure and a good creative half.

 

I'm not ignoring anything, a creative lock isn't as good as a creative half imo at starting backline movements, which is what a good running fullback relies on. A creative fullback works better around the middle of the ruck of the back of hookers and forward play and In broken play, whereas a running fulback plays at the edges and is more like Karmicheal who will either step or fend through gaps.

 

Minni relied on his superb tackle break ablility, which requires him to get into half gaps, and what i have seen of stewart shows him as more of a finisher, particularly at the end of backline movments, granted I hate manly and don't watch there games all that often.

As for K, he never really played as a creative fullback IMO much more off a running game, at least until towards the end off this year. or when Lockyer wasn't playing through Injury.

 

See I would say the best way to create gaps is to spread the defence which you can do best by a good backline movement, this is how brisbane have been so successful for years.

 

Really, are you serious.

Have you not heard of the concept of examples.

IMO the best examples currently of "creative" fullbacks are Billy Slater and Jarryd Hayne both of whom do most of there damage in the middle off second phase play. These are players who are capable of creating somthing out of nothing, as compared to relying on hitting the line at speed, but rather createing there own gaps and spaces to make line breaks.