Yeh but if you knew that you got tactical kicking from being a 10, it gave you an advantage over all other 10s. Would make it better, and fairer if you told everyone what bonuses each position gives you.
I think he just means that each position (especially specialist ones) get a natural ability to do "their job". So anyone playing 10 would have a modicum of skill with tactical kicking - he's just chosen to not take it to Dan Carter proportions. Similarly any wing would have a natural ability for speed, but you could pump that further if you chose, etc etc.
It's not about post count. Post rank, and it isn't all about that. Benny is far from the best CricSim player, is he not?
That's what I meant. But this is more like the new RL than cricsim, so a higher post rank will likely = better stats. But hopefully this won't be as bad where 40% of your attributes is from your post rank.
40% is a reasonable number. I'd say this is about that. How else do you recommend they are generated?
A lower % being based on post rank? Others may disagree, though. Just kind of sucks when you have someone being good at everything just because their post rank is high.