morgieb's Draft Review

Discussion in 'CPL Aussie Rules' started by morgieb, Apr 9, 2013.

  1. morgieb MC Burridge

    289. Masters – Tyson Goldsack
    290. MightyPies/Heef – Michael Rischitelli
    291. Mousey/Teacups – Shane Edwards
    292. Benny - Adam Schneider
    293. Skippos - Arryn Siposs
    294. Shagger - Mark Jamar
    295. Jimmy_c8 - Brock McLean
    296. Diggler - Jared Polec
    297. Harps - Jake King
    298. Theo - Patrick Karnezis
    299. Jager – Rhys Palmer
    300. Nino – Lenny Hayes
    301. Oz – Matthew Broadbent
    302. Morgie – Luke McGuane
    303. Brett – Daniel Kerr
    304. Jabba – Nick Maxwell

    Best: I don't care how old he is, it's Hayes. Kerr, Rischitelli and McLean were quality picks too.

    Worst: Probably Schneider, he's aging, and doesn't regularly play now.
     
  2. morgieb MC Burridge

    305. Jabba – David Myers
    306. Brett – Leigh Adams
    307. Morgie – Brent Harvey
    308. Oz – Heath Scotland
    309. Nino – Jonathan Giles
    310. Jager – Brent Guerra
    311. Theo – Jude Bolton
    312. Harps – Nick Duigan
    313. Diggler – George Horlin-Smith
    314. Jimmy_c8 – Danny Stanley
    315. Shagger – Marty Clarke
    316. Skippos – Lachie Whitfield
    317. Benny – Ash McGrath
    318. Mousey/Teacups – Darren Jolly
    319. MightyPies/Heef – Chris Knights
    320. Masters – Tendai Mzungu

    Best: Toss-up between Jolly and Giles. To pick up a quality ruckman this late is a great piece of work. Whitfield will be a steal at this rate, and Harvey, Bolton and Scotland despite their ages were nice pick-ups too.

    Worst: Probably Myers, he's still fairly young but he's hardly a regular for a club which wasn't exactly outstanding. Has improved this year though.
     
  3. morgieb MC Burridge

    321. Masters – Billie Smedts
    322. MightyPies/Heef – Brent Macaffer
    323. Mousey/Teacups – Joel Corey
    324. Benny - Sean Dempster
    325. Skippos - Aaron Mullett
    326. Shagger - Ashton Hams
    327. Jimmy_c8 - Alwyn Davey
    328. Diggler - Anthony Morabito
    329. Harps - Bradley Hill
    330. Theo - Chad Cornes
    331. Jager – Joel Patfull
    332. Nino – Scott Gumbleton
    333. Oz – Max Bailey
    334. Morgie – Brad Crouch
    335. Brett – Rhys Stanley
    336. Jabba – Brian Lake

    Best: Probably Benny for getting an AA defender this late in the game. Patfull also a good pick, as are Corey and Lake.

    Worst: Taking Crouch, Mullett and Morabito are pretty big punts given their lack of experience. But they should be steals at this rate. Cornes is also a major risk, given his career is probably done.

    The actual worst is either Stanley or Davey, but Davey was one of the better smalls left and Stanley is still developing, could be a quality player.
     
  4. morgieb MC Burridge

    337. Jabba – Mike Pyke
    338. Brett – Brett Goodes
    339. Morgie – Sam Dwyer
    340. Oz – Jake Neade
    341. Nino – David Hille
    342. Jager – Majak Daw
    343. Theo – Liam Jones
    344. Harps – Sam Gibson
    345. Diggler – Mark Nicoski
    346. Jimmy_c8 – Kade Simpson
    347. Shagger – Max Gawn
    348. Skippos – Joe Daniher
    349. Benny – Andrejs Everitt
    350. Mousey/Teacups – Jake Stringer
    351. MightyPies/Heef – Daniel Giansiracusa
    352. Masters – Lachie Plowman

    Best: Definitely Simpson. He's a quality mid who isn't too old. Pyke seems to be turning into a quality player, and is a key player who slid.

    Worst: A lot of punts here, with even a player without AFL experience being taken. Probably gonna give it to Dwyer though, given he only just broke into the AFL and hasn't really been that good either.
     
  5. morgieb MC Burridge

    353. Masters - Nick Vlastuin
    354. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Golby
    355. Mousey/Teacups – Dion Prestia
    356. Benny – Thomas Lynch
    357. Skippos – Rory Thompson
    358. Shagger – Colin Garland
    359. Jimmy_c8 – Jeremy Laidler
    360. Diggler – Kyle Hardingham
    361. Harps – Kieren Harper
    362. Theo – Kane Lucas
    363. Jager –
    364. Nino – Dylan Roberton
    365. Oz – Taylor Adams
    366. Morgie – Justin Koschitzke
    367. Brett – David MacKay
    368. Jabba – Rohan Bewick

    Best: Harper, Adams, Prestia and Roberton come to mind. Roberton probably the best of the four.

    Worst: Probably Garland, he seems to be very average. Koschitzke also worth mentioning, his career seems spent also he is versatile.
     
  6. MASTERS S Masters

    not a fan of Kane Lucas ? not a bid pick for this stage
     
  7. Skippos SM Morgan

    Tom Lynch hands down best pick of the round bar none. Top draft pick, KPF - developing at a good rate and performed better than most KPFs his age. Most KPFs worse than him went 10 rounds earlier.

    Rory Thompson would be pretty much the Jake Carlisle-esque reputation in the media if he were in Melbourne, ftr. Looks a real good key back.
     
  8. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Agree with SF about Lucas
     
  9. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah Lucas a nice pick. Prestia and Adams better though IMO
     
  10. morgieb MC Burridge

    Meh I prefer others to Lucas.

    Fair enough about Lynch. Wasn't sure which one Benny went with though.
     
  11. Dirk Diggler DM Diggler

    Lynch :(
     
    Last edited: May 1, 2013
  12. Shagger PW Adams

    so cut skippo got thompson a pick before me.
     
  13. Skippos SM Morgan

    Ugh hrovats a gun :(
     
  14. Benny BS Read

    Moar.
     
  15. morgieb MC Burridge

    369. Jabba – Rohan Bail
    370. Brett – Clinton Young
    371. Morgie – Sam Mayes
    372. Oz – Thomas Young
    373. Nino – Lee Spurr
    374. Jager – Devon Smith
    375. Theo – Robbie Warnock
    376. Harps – Campbell Heath
    377. Diggler – Zac Clarke
    378. Jimmy_c8 – Trent West
    379. Shagger – Cameron O'Shea
    380. Skippos – Jason Winderlich
    381. Benny – Simon Black
    382. Mousey/Teacups – Jono O'Rourke
    383. MightyPies/Heef – Beau Maister
    384. Masters - Jordie McKenzie

    Best: Warnock a cracker of a pick this late, he's pretty good. Black an excellent pick too, and Mayes is potentially a steal at this rate.

    Worst: Probably Rohan Bail at this stage. He's not very young and isn't a regular for his side. O'Shea not a great one either.
     
  16. morgieb MC Burridge

    385. Masters - Matthew Watson
    386. MightyPies/Heef – Nick Lower
    387. Mousey/Teacups – Gary Rohan
    388. Benny – Rhyce Shaw
    389. Skippos – Jesse Hogan
    390. Shagger – David Rodan
    391. Jimmy_c8 – Kepler Bradley
    392. Diggler – Elliott Kavanagh
    393. Harps – Claye Beams
    394. Theo – Ben Griffiths
    395. Jager – Jacob Townsend
    396. Nino – Jake Melksham
    397. Oz – Nathan Hrovat
    398. Morgie – Dean Brogan
    399. Brett – Dom Tyson
    400. Jabba – Lynden Dunn

    Best: Rhyce Shaw. Potentially bias but why he lasted to the 25th round or something makes no sense. Hogan potentially a major steal, but as he won't play for a year it's hard to judge, and Tyson was taken very high in his draft (although he's fallen off the radar slightly). Bradley and Brogan are decent picks, filling potential KP gaps.

    Worst: While Watson and Kavanagh are fairly young, they're still generally second-rate right now, and I haven't really heard much hype about them. Ditto Griffiths.
     
  17. brettman135 BR Hall

    Because Griffiths is a plodder. Also Dom Tyson has been out with a knee injury all season.
     
  18. Dirk Diggler DM Diggler

    You pick out Kavanagh and Watson but not Hogan who won't play in the AFL for another 12 months?
     
  19. morgieb MC Burridge

    Difference is I've heard hype around Hogan but not so much around the other two blokes.
     
  20. Dirk Diggler DM Diggler

    The others are top 20 picks. If Hogan actually rates higher than others I'll rage quit.
     

Share This Page